Underfunded HOA Reserves: How to Tell, Why It Happens, and How to Fix It

An HOA's reserves are considered underfunded when the association doesn't have enough money set aside to cover the future repair and replacement of its major common-area components. 

The clearest way to measure it is a metric called percent funded: as a general industry benchmark, a reserve account below 70% funded is considered underfunded and at elevated risk of a special assessment, while a community at or above 70% is on much steadier ground.

The trouble is that most boards don’t know where they stand until something goes wrong.

How to Tell If Your HOA Reserves Are Underfunded

You don't need to wait for a roof to fail to know your reserves are behind. 

There are three key signs that you are underfunded.

1. Your percent funded is below 70% 

This is the single most reliable indicator. Percent funded compares what your association currently has in reserves against what it should have at this point in time, according to your reserve study. 

At 100%, you're fully funded. Between 70% and 100%, you're in good shape. Below 70%, the risk of a special assessment climbs, and below 30% you're in a danger zone where a single major repair can force an emergency levy. 

If you don't know your percent funded, that itself is a warning sign - it means no current reserve study is guiding your budget.

2. You're relying on special assessments

If your association has issued one or more special assessments in recent years to cover repairs that should have been planned for, this is a huge red flag.

Healthy reserves exist precisely so that predictable expenses don't become surprise bills.

3. You have visible deferred maintenance

If you have visible maintenance issues that are being deferred rather than maintained, this is a clear sign that your reserve may be underfunded and not able to cover repairs.

What Causes Underfunded HOA Reserves

These are some of the most common reasons why your HOA reserves might be underfunded:

• Dues set too low for too long. The most common cause. Boards keep assessments flat to stay popular with owners, and contributions never keep pace with the true cost of future repairs.
• No reserve study, or an outdated one. Without a current study, the board is budgeting on guesswork. Component costs and conditions change, and a study that's several years stale almost always understates what's needed.
• Underestimated costs and inflation. Repair and construction costs have increased rapidly in the last few years -  a study that is a few years old can quickly become out of date.
• High delinquency rates. When owners don't pay their dues and the board doesn't pursue collections, the money flowing into reserves shrinks.
• Borrowing from reserves. When the operating budget runs short, some boards quietly "borrow" from reserves to cover day-to-day costs - and never establish a plan to pay it back.
• Large, unanticipated expenses. A major repair that wasn't planned for can drain a reserve fund quickly, especially in associations that were already running lean.

An udnerfunded reserve can put you at risk of many things.

The Risks of Leaving Reserves Underfunded

It can be tempting to keep dues low and hope for the best. 

This is typically a recipe for disaster though, and here are some of the main reasons why.

Special assessments

When reserves can't cover a major repair, the board has little choice but to levy a special assessment - often thousands of dollars per owner, due on short notice. These create genuine financial hardship and frequently spark disputes with the board.

Higher long-term costs

Deferred repairs don't go away; they get worse. A small roof issue postponed for years becomes a full replacement. Underfunding today almost always means spending more tomorrow.

Falling property values and stalled sales 

Buyers and their agents increasingly review an association's reserve health before purchasing. An underfunded reserve account signals financial instability, scares off buyers worried about looming assessments, and can make units harder to sell.

Financing and insurance friction

Mortgage lenders consider reserve health when approving loans in a community, and insurers increasingly factor it into coverage and premiums. Weak reserves can affect every owner's ability to sell or refinance.

Possible legal and fiduciary exposure 

In some states, reserve funding is a legal requirement - Florida now mandates fully funded structural reserves for many condominium associations, for example. 

Even where it isn't required by statute, an association's governing documents may mandate reserve funding, and a board that ignores them may be exposed to claims of breaching its fiduciary duty.

How to Fix Underfunded HOA Reserves

The good news: underfunded reserves are fixable, and the path back is well-established. 

The steps below work best in combination, and they all start from the same foundation.

1. Get a current reserve study

This is the essential first step, because you can't fix a shortfall you haven't measured. A professional reserve study inventories every major component, assesses its condition and remaining useful life, calculates your current percent funded, and lays out a multi-year funding plan to close the gap. 

Everything that follows depends on the numbers a study provides. Without one, you're guessing; with one, you have a roadmap.

2. Raise regular contributions gradually

Increasing dues is the most sustainable fix. 

Rather than a single jarring jump, a series of moderate, planned increases lets reserves catch up while spreading the impact on owners. Communicating clearly why the increase is needed - backed by the reserve study - goes a long way toward owner buy-in.

3. Build a catch-up funding plan

A good reserve study won't just tell you that you're behind; it will model how to recover. A catch-up (or "threshold") funding plan sets a target percent funded and charts the contribution path to reach it over a set number of years. 

This turns an intimidating shortfall into a manageable, scheduled climb.

4. Reduce operating costs where you can

Renegotiating vendor contracts or finding efficiencies in the operating budget can free up money to redirect into reserves - without cutting essential services or deferring the very maintenance that causes problems.

5. Consider a loan or special assessment for urgent gaps

When a critical repair can't wait for reserves to recover, a special assessment or an association loan can bridge the gap. 

A loan spreads the cost over time rather than hitting owners all at once, while a special assessment avoids debt but is far less popular. Both are best treated as bridges to a properly funded plan, not substitutes for one.

Getting Your Reserves Back on Track

Underfunded reserves don't fix themselves, but they also don't have to end in a crisis. The associations that recover are the ones that measure the problem honestly, then follow a funded plan to close the gap before a major component forces their hand.

That starts with knowing exactly where you stand. Reserve Study Group helps HOAs and condominium associations measure their percent funded, understand their shortfall, and build a realistic catch-up plan - in clear reports written for board members, not engineers. 

Learn more about how much an HOA should have in reserves or request a proposal to get a current study for your community.

Frequently Asked Questions

• What percent funded is considered underfunded? As a general benchmark, below 70% funded is considered underfunded, and below 30% is a high-risk danger zone where special assessments become likely. At or above 70% is generally considered a strong, stable position.
• Is it illegal to have underfunded HOA reserves? It depends on your state and governing documents. Some states - notably Florida for many condominium associations - now legally require reserve funding. Elsewhere it may not be mandated by statute, but your association's governing documents may still require it, and underfunding can expose the board to fiduciary-duty claims.
• How do I find out my HOA's percent funded? It comes from a current reserve study, which compares your actual reserve balance against the recommended balance for your components' age and condition. If your association doesn't have a recent study, getting one is the first step.
• Can an underfunded HOA recover without a special assessment? Often, yes - through a gradual dues increase paired with a catch-up funding plan, provided the shortfall is caught before a major component fails. The earlier you act, the more options you have.

‍

‍